By Farooq Sulehria
The political mullahs rub salt into the wounds of earthquake victims
every time they shoot their mouths off blaming 'sinful' people
for earning the 'wrath of God' in the form of the recent earthquake.
Without a shred of respect for a generation of innocent schoolchildren
lost to the disaster, MMA President Qazi Hussain Ahmed attributing
the earthquake to a 'sinful' nation, declares the earthquake a
'warning by God' and sermons on the urgency of modifying lifestyles.
His parliamentarian daughter, Rahila Qazi, indicates that a 'barrage
of obscenity unleashed on the media under the government sponsorship'
as the cause for the 'wrath of God'.
These 'wrath-of-God' theories invoked in the wake of natural
catastrophes are not Pakistan-specific. Despite the 'clash of
civilisations', theology sans humanity cuts across 'civilisational'
divisions. Recently, evangelists in the USA blamed lesbian/gay
and pro-choice people for Hurricane Katrina while a contributor
on the Christian Broadcasting Network website wrote: 'Whenever
this country encourages Israel to give up any part of their rightful
God-given land we have suffered the consequences.' No Christian
fanatic in the USA, however, attributed the disaster to child
abuse in the Catholic church!
Earlier, when the tsunami hit Buddhist Sri Lanka, Hindu India,
Muslim Indonesia alike, clerical justifications cut across all
religious divisions: Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, Christianity.
In Sri Lanka, Buddhists recalled the story of a tsunami which
hit the island circa 200 BC when a king killed a Buddhist monk
in a fit of anger. They wondered which of their political leaders
angered the sea gods this time.
Hindu fundamentalists blamed their government for earning the
wrath of the gods by arresting, in November 2004, their spiritual
leader Kanchi Shankracharya.
Certain Christian groups thought the tsunami was a just punishment
for countries that were treating their Christian populations badly
(one wonders why Pakistan was spared.)
In Israel, Sephardic chief rabbi Shlomo Amar said that the tragedy
was 'an _expression of God's wrath with the world. The world is
being punished for wrongdoing -- be it people's needless hatred
of each other, lack of charity, or moral turpitude'.
No doubt, some natural disasters are natural in their causation
but are aggravated or mitigated by arrangements, or lack of them,
provided by the states and societies. Last-year's tsunami, hurricane
Katrina and the recent earthquake in Kashmir show that the natural
catastrophic effects of natural disasters are determined by the
policies followed by the governments. In godless Cuba, the government
efficiently evacuates million-and-a half people before hurricanes
while in God-fearing USA Katrina leaves 1200 dead. The enormity
of misery befallen the people of Kashmir is in no way a product
of God's wrath. A lot has to do with the policies Islamabad has
pursued vis--vis Kashmir; Islamabad never built any proper
Even when people in Pakistan and the rest of the world, are generously
donating towards the relief efforts, it is not certain if relief
will reach in time owing to the poor infrastructure. Access to
500 villages wiped off the face of the earth is not possible without
helicopters since there are few roads built to link villages.
Relief from abroad could not reach in time because there is no
airport. This despite the fact that a large number of people from
the area are settled abroad. This utter lack of infrastructure
has enhanced the enormity of the catastrophe that shook Kashmir
on the morning of October 8.
True, the government of Pakistan could not evacuate the people
of Kashmir since the earthquake hit, unlike hurricanes, without
prior knowledge. But certain similarities between Kashmir and
New Orleans are striking.
Also, natural disasters pick on the poor and the weak, rather
than the privileged. None of the political mullahs lost family
members or were rendered homeless. Not because they are the chosen
ones. But because all mainstream political mullahs enjoy life
in concretely built luxury villas. Despite abundant natural wealth,
majority of the Kashmiri population lives in poverty. Thus, if
the earthquake was a natural disaster, it was aggravated by poverty
and decades of neglect.
Also, we cannot attribute this 'mountain tsunami' as a warning
to General Musharraf, despite what critics of his regime say.
Neither can we blame the 'obscene' media as some mullahs and right
wing columnists are trying to do. If divine wisdom is meant to
punish innocent citizens for the deeds of a military ruler, then
the Hasba-billed, MMA-ruled NWFP should have been spared God's
wrath. If media obscenity and 'unIslamic' rulers of Pakistan are
to be blamed then what about Iran which was hit twice by earthquakes
in the last six years despite its pure media and puritan Islamic
government. Similarly Afghanistan experienced two earthquakes
(1999 and Feb 2001) while the Taliban were running Kabul and Radio
Shariat would not broadcast anything but the word of God.
Above all, earthquakes are known to occur even before the 'sinful'
descendants of Adam and Eve inhabited mother earth. Who was, in
those good old days, God angry at?
Meanwhile, BBC reports that God asked Bush to invade Afghanistan
and Iraq. Surely, the gods must be crazy!
The writer is a freelance journalist based in Sweden